How the Credit Card Settlement Will Affect the 10 States That Have Prohibitive Laws Regarding Surcharging?

Scott E. Blakeley, Esq.

In light of the pending Credit Card Settlement Agreement, that if approved would allow vendors to pass on any surcharges from the credit card companies to customers, 10 states still have codified statutes that prohibit surcharging.

The 10 prohibitive states are California, New York, Florida, Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, Maine, Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Colorado. Many of the states on the list are major players in the national economy.

The language from the California version of the code states:

“No retailer in any sales, service, or lease transaction with a consumer may impose a surcharge on a cardholder who elects to use a credit card in lieu of payment by cash, check, or similar means. A retailer may, however, offer discounts for the purpose of inducing payment by cash, check, or other means not involving the use of a credit card, provided that the discount is offered to all prospective buyers (Ca. Civ. Code 1748.1(a)).”

The codes addressed above all have similar language with similar effects. It is important to notice that the language of the California code, much like all the other states codified language, does not differentiate between business to business and business to consumer settings.

Vendors in these 10 states may believe that with the settlement agreement, they can now have transparency in passing on the surcharge to customers. However, if the settlement terms were to take effect, these 10 states would not be influenced by the agreement in any way. Instead, vendors in these 10 states will have to rely on the same old tactics currently used.

A key means to bypassing the surcharge prohibition is to create a two tiered price system. One price includes the base price for the product and factors in the surcharge average (whether it be 0.5% or 3%). The other price, often referred to as the “cash discount” is just the base price without the surcharge fee factored in. In order not to run afoul with the Robinson-Patman Act a vendor must offer both prices to all its customers in order to avoid any sort of price discrimination.

Another means of avoiding the state law prohibition is to merely raise prices factoring in surcharge into the price increase. This tactic avoids the two price list system and offers the same “base” price to all customers regardless of their payment method.

While the settlement agreement will affect a large portion of vendors around the country, the states mentioned above will not see a change and vendors must continue to use means to recover surcharges passed on to them from the credit card companies from their customers.

19 Responses to “How the Credit Card Settlement Will Affect the 10 States That Have Prohibitive Laws Regarding Surcharging?”

  1. boutiqueshoes4us

    cheapnikeairmax2012, lampistamataro,

  2. nike air max tailwind 8 men shoe bright gold brown for sale

    air jordan nu retro 2shopping cheap nike zoom crusader black blue sliver 650987 004nike air pegasus 89cheap nike air max 270 flyknit black orange australia

  3. nike womens air huarache bronzine

    gourmet sedici camoair jordan 1 kids pinnacle white outletoriginal tennis low leather cream navy rednew running shoes womens nike roshe run painted pink floral navy white hot punch

  4. men supra skytop black grey skate shoes

    nike baseball shoesnike air force 1 low meilleur prix homme canvas navy menbape 1st camo parkasupra recap 2012

  5. new style nike free 40 v2 womens shoes grey purple eu20017

    men white nike shoxadidas nmdr2 shoes pink adidas ukair jordan true flight vs 7air jordan 11 retro 2018 off white nike

  6. nike flyknit air max vivid blueblack atomic orange

    men nike kobe xi basketball shoes low 350 new arrivalnike air tech challenge ii deep garnetcheap real adidas nmd r2 blue black whitenike free 5.0 v4 black and cheetah print

  7. nike air jordan 9 retro olive 2012

    nike zoom kd v elite klein durant basketball shoes for men in 93988nike air max peach orange shoes for womenusa mint speckle nike zoom kd 6nike air more uptempo 96 doernbecher blue jay red orange ah6949 446

  8. nike sb janoski zoom grey

    womens nike air max 1 87 shoes mint turquoise red blackonline shop 2016 mens nike free 665k shoes black white clearance onlinecheap mens nike kyrie 4 black gold shoes for salecheap jordan shoes size 11

  9. nike sb zoom stefan janoski mid red leather

    nike frees all black nike air max essential 1 blue striking fashion

  10. adidas nmd branco e azul

    nike cortez premium baseball pack2016 lake erie nike lebron 13 white blue for salefifa world cup nike magista turf soccer boots white green blackadidas originals pro model gtx boot blackblack

  11. sacs homme sacs bandouli猫re nike tech small items rouge rouge

    2017 air jordan 11 nike air jordan 11 frture gris et blanche femme jordanakademie nike air huarache kinder sand c70445adidas zx flux adv hombrezvezdochka by marc newson and nike

  12. femme adidas tubular shadow rouge

    nike air max modern flyknit ceneo kolekcjanike huarache bambini biancopure platinumbianco scarpe nike blazer mid canottenike roshe run midnight navy dark obsidianoff white x nike blazer mid grim reaper sneakerb0b releas

  13. online sale mens nike free 50 light grey black dark grey running shoes

    adidas concord ii mid groupwomens nike air max 270 barely grey black light pumicenike air force 1 low supreme comme des garcons shirtds nike sb dunk low black supreme size 9 1000 obo

  14. nike air max 97 ultra 7 metallic silver varsity red black for sale

    854 215635 nike lebron 10 mid top black silvernavy adidas i 5923 collegiateair jordan 11 2019nike air vapormax flyknit off white

  15. nike soldier vii hombre

    nike dunk high premium day of the dead donnanike yellow synthetic superfly 6 academy football femmenike hyperdisruptor herrescarpe nike air huarache drift premium uomo

  16. mens nike shox nz running shoes white black logo electroplate button

    michael jordan eclipsenike free run 5.0 black and rednike new jordans 2 ii retro original air cushion black cool greyadidas zx 700 trainers red white

  17. nike air force 1 mita

    nike lebron 13 galaxy purple black glow in the dark basketball shoesnike free 4 0 v3 mens black red royal blue running shoesuw88u56 black white air jordan 11 low shoes for mensnike vintage air force hitop

  18. adidas swift run collegiate navy mens heren

    chaussures medicom x nike air force 1 berbrickreebok npc uk herrenike uomo pre montreal suede nylon sneakers blunike benassi ltd uomo

  19. nike kd 6 elite bleu orange basket leopard

    nike air max thea for sale philippinesmarkowe buty m臋skie buty nike air max 90 premium cobblestonenike kyrie 4 black gold gum soleelegir nike free 3.0 v4 mujer negro fluorescente verde zapatillas online

Leave a Reply